Which Tomato For Sandwich? – 10 Best Tomatoes For Sandwiches

Are you a big fan of sandwiches? You are striving for a new flavor of this classic recipe? And you start to wonder: Which tomato for sandwich will bring the best flavor?  Tomato is an …

Which Tomato For Sandwich

Are you a big fan of sandwiches? You are striving for a new flavor of this classic recipe? And you start to wonder: Which tomato for sandwich will bring the best flavor? 

Tomato is an important part of a sandwich. There are many options for gourmet eaters based on size, color, and taste.

In this article, we will list the 10 best tomato variants to brighten up this dish!

Which Tomato For Sandwich? – 10 Best Heirloom Tomatoes

Mortgage Lifter Tomato

Mortgage Lifter is a large-scale tomato that has the unique shape of beefsteak. This variety, on average, weighs about 1 – 2 pounds and is triple as big as the normal tomato. 

One feature that distinguishes the Mortgage Lifter from other varieties is super meaty. Moreover, its meaty texture is very soft and juicy. When combined with other ingredients, you can still taste its authentic flavor very clearly. Only one slice of Mortgage can cover the whole big bread.


Here comes the classic heirloom variety of tomato for the gourmet. In comparison with Mortgage Lifter, Brandywine is one and a half larger. However, both of them have a pink peel and meaty texture. 

Brandywine is an open-pollinated plant; most of them are grown in the summer. Regarding nutrition facts, this plant is rich in vitamin A, vitamin D, and especially low-acidic and low-sugar. Therefore, it is extremely fresh and healthy. To have the best sandwich flavor, you had better serve them with cheese.

Black Krim Tomato

Compared with other conventional red tomatoes, this purple-brown variant is really one of a kind. Black Krim has a bold dark purple peel on the top and fades into red on the bottom. 

In terms of size, this dark species is just as small as the globe tomato. Additionally, Black Krim is very distinctive from other beefsteak heirloom varieties as it is tart and salty in flavor. Therefore, a diner who loves experiencing new tastes can consider this choice.

Black Krim

Green Zebra

This is another outstanding variety in the sandwich tomato portfolio due to its unique pattern. True to its name, Green Zebra has a green coat with yellow stripes. This variety is extraordinarily smaller than other species; you can even hold it in one hand. 

When eaten with bread, it brings you a mixture of tart and sweet taste. Besides, this plant is also healthy as it covers high amounts of nutrients such as carbs, calcium, and potassium. 

Early Girl

Early girl is a medium-size tomato that is grown in the short term in the fall. This variety is similar to the globe tomatoes, weighing 4-6 ounces. 

Regarding flavor, although it is not as sweet as Mortgage or Brandywine, it exudes an intense homemade tomato smell. Furthermore, it is also rich in nutrients such as carbs, vitamin A, sodium, and sugar.

Cherokee Purple

The name Cherokee Purple relates closely to the color of the tomato. This Tennessee variety has a purple-brown layout, similar to the Black Rim. The difference between these two species is the size; Cherokee is half the Black Rim. 

This variety is juicy from the inside; it can soften your bread if it’s been in the sandwich for a long time. Not only is Cherokee famous for its firm-yet-fine texture and classic flavor, but it is also regarded as a rich nutrient source. It is chock-full of vitamin A and vitamin K, which strengthens your bones, and antioxidants, which boost your immune system.

Cherokee Purple

Big Boy

As the name suggests, this tomato is large in scale. It is truly a hybrid variety that was initiated by Krymsk in Eastern Europe. Its peel is smooth and red, measuring from 8-10 ounces. 

Moreover, Big Boy is most favored as the perfect match for every kind of bread due to its juicy taste and firm texture. Most of this tomato is carbs and protein, which supports your digestion system.

Kellogg’s Breakfast

Kellogg gains a big reputation due to its vibrant color. It has smooth yellow skin which makes it extremely outstanding among other varieties. 

When it comes to size, Kellogg’s size is equivalent to Mortgage’s, and both of them are 1-2 pounds heavy. In addition, this plant’s sweet and tangy flavor is a match made in heaven with the soft texture of the bread. Besides, the amount of carbs in Kellogg’s is also beneficial for health.


Pineapple is the most attractive species in this list either by its color or its taste. Yellow skin with orange stripes running down makes it look like real tropical fruit. 

When mixing with bread, you will feel the tangy taste and some flavor of tropical fruit. Therefore, no other tomatoes can substitute Pineapple in terms of smell. Not to mention, it is also an abundant source of carbs and protein for your immune system.

Raf tomato

Amish Paste Tomato

An excellent cooking tomato is the Amish Paste. You can eat it fresh or cooked. Within 65 to 80 days, it is ready. It is a variety that was developed in the 1870s in Medford, Wisconsin, and has been passed down from generation to generation with its distinctive red skin and flesh.

Amish Paste is ideal for both preparing the tastiest tomato sauces and for eating fresh. The different shapes range from 6 to 12 ounces in weight. This type needs to be staked and has a lot of seeds.

Ways To Make It Extra Fancy

If you are bored of conventional bread with cheese and tomatoes, try to do something new. Innovating some ingredients in the sandwich can make a huge difference. Here are some methods you can look up:

  • Bake the cheese in conjunction with the bread
  • Switch to other types of bread such as ciabatta, flatbread, and bagels.
  • Add various kinds of vegetables 
  • Fill it up with some pate

All of these methods can deliver flavors to your meal. As long as you don’t get them burned, you will have a unique extra fancy sandwich that nobody has. Besides, eating a sandwich and drinking soda is also a good idea.


Which tomato for sandwich? The above article has listed for you the 10 best tomatoes for sandwiches. That depends: the choice varies based on personal preferences. If you want an original sweet flavor, you should try Mortgage Lifter and Brandywine. Should you prefer a tweak in taste, try out Black Krim and Green Zebra. 

To sum up, a tomato is an indispensable part of a sandwich; without its freshness and juiciness, your dishes will taste like tedious bread with meat and butter. 

Furthermore, tomatoes can also boost your health equivalently due to the rich nutrients it provides. If you find this list informative, please leave your comment below!